Cruelty Party Tanner Mayes New -

Another angle: could this be a typo or misremembered name? For example, "Tanner Mayes" might be a misspelling of "Tanner McHenry," who is a real person (a musician), but that doesn't fit. Alternatively, maybe "Tanner Mayes" is a character from a book or another movie, perhaps a lesser-known production.