Agbayani’s decision to model for Playboy was met with mixed reactions. Critics argued that such platforms objectified women, while supporters framed it as an exercise of autonomy and self-expression. Agbayani herself has emphasized that the opportunity allowed her to redefine her image and connect with a broader audience, showcasing her agency in navigating the entertainment industry. The April 2005 issue featuring Agbayani (sometimes colloquially referred to as "12 Extra" in online communities) was lauded for its artistic direction, blending high fashion with Playboy ’s signature bold aesthetic. Photographer and stylist credits highlight the professionalism of the shoot, which avoided overtly exploitative imagery and instead focused on empowerment and individuality.